JOHN SCHMEELK: I’ll lay low on Trindon Holliday here as well, and go with first round pick Odell Beckham Jr, who showed the quickness and explosion in college to be an excellent punt returner.
DAN SALOMONE: Trindon Holliday. At 5-foot-5, he’s a unique talent that became the first player in NFL history to score multiple return touchdowns in a single postseason game with his previous team, the Denver Broncos. While blocking has been part of the reason, the Giants’ punt returners haven’t helped out the field position battle in recent years. Holliday can do that and more, but he has to hang onto the football.