2018 Bracket Challenge: Jeff Feagles vs. Kareem McKenzie 
 

P Jeff Feagles

Years with NYG: 2003-09

The longest-tenured player in NFL history spent the last seven seasons of his 22-year career with the Giants, including the 2007 title campaign. Feagles is first in league history in career punts, punting yards and punts inside the 20. Feagles twice pinned the Patriots inside their own 12-yard line in Super Bowl XLII.

VS.

OT Kareem McKenzie

Years with NYG: 2005-11

A former Jet, McKenzie was the starting right tackle on the Giants' last two Super Bowl-winning teams. In all, McKenzie started 116 games at the position for one of the best offensive lines in the NFL, including 11 postseason contests.