Skip to main content
New York Giants homepage
Advertising

Giants News | New York Giants – Giants.com

Cover 3

Presented by

Cover 3: Final thoughts as countdown to training camp begins

ABDUL-CARTER-COVER-3

With spring practices now complete, the Giants.com crew discuss their final takeaways from the spring as the countdown to training camp has officially begun.

John Schmeelk: The Giants are better. Fine, I will be more specific. This Giants team is deeper. When I judge a roster's depth, I like to think about what the last week of August will look like and how the final 53-man roster is put together. How difficult will some of these decisions be? How many players that the Giants don't place on their 53-man roster will be claimed or picked up by another team? Far too often over the last decade, the answer to the first question was "not very" and the answer to the second was none.

I believe the answers to those questions will be different this year. The Giants are going to have to let go some talented players on the defensive line after the additions of Roy Roberston-Harris and Jeremiah Ledbetter as free agents and Darius Alexander in the draft. The offensive line is not going to be easy, either. The five starters from last year plus James Hudson III, Aaron Stinnie, Evan Neal and Marcus Mbow gets you to nine, and I haven't even mentioned Jake Kubas, Josh Ezeudu, Stone Forsythe, or either backup center in Austin Schlottmann and Jimmy Morrissey.

The end of the wide receiver depth chart will be tough to sort out with the four primary receivers at the top of the depth chart (Darius Slayton, Wan'Dale Robinson, Malik Nabers, Jalin Hyatt), the team's primary returner in Ihmir Smith-Marsette, and then a talented undrafted free agent class and veterans with pelts on the wall fighting for whatever is left. It's rare that teams keep six wide receivers on their active roster.

Do the Giants keep four tight ends or will they have to say good bye to one of Theo Johnson, Daniel Bellinger, Chris Manhertz or Thomas Fidone II? Greg Dulcich is another talented player they may have to account for. At running back do the Giants keep anyone beyond Tyrone Tracy Jr., Devin Singletary and Cam Skattebo?

Four years of Joe Schoen drafts and free agency moves has made the roster thicker. There are things we still don't know that will determine what the season looks like. What young players improve to the point where they raise their performance to Pro Bowl levels? What's the production from the quarterback room, which features three brand new players? Those are the things that drive the performance of a football team. But I have no doubt the roster is better. I look forward to seeing how that pays off on the field.

See all of the action from Giants Minicamp at the Quest Diagnostics Training Center.

Dan Salomone: Darius Slayton, the longest-tenured Giant on offense, said it best at the end of OTAs: The 2025 quarterback room is an "interesting compilation of individuals."

The Giants entered the offseason with the primary goal of addressing the most important position in sports and did so with only Tommy DeVito on the roster. After the first wave of free agency brought defensive backs, not quarterbacks, the ball eventually got rolling with Jameis Winston and Russell Wilson shortly thereafter. Not backed into a corner anymore, the Giants were then allowed to draft the best player available regardless of position and took All-American edge rusher Abdul Carter. They still needed to address the future at quarterback, however, leading them to trade up for Jaxson Darter.

So, the biggest takeaway from the spring is how it has unfolded in that quarterback room.

"When you have a group like we have, none of them are afraid to speak and say anything that is on their mind," offensive passing game coordinator/quarterbacks coach Shea Tierney said. "Russ, Jameis, Tommy, who has been in the system longer than any of them, and Jaxson too is getting comfortable with that. I think when you have that group that's willing to do that, it permeates throughout the rest of the offense, and we've seen that in our meetings. Guys are really willing to have those discussions that help in OTAs that lead to now we don't have to have that discussion in training camp because we already did it."

Wilson, who has known Tierney since his early days at N.C. State, is leading the way on that front.

"I knew him as a young kid; I was a young kid," said Tierney, who began his coaching career as a graduate assistant for the Wolfpack. "We joke all the time that we came up together. Our formative years in football were side by side. So, Russ hasn't changed. He's the same guy he was when he was 18 years old. He still has a great work ethic, prepares every day like it's new for him, takes notes. He is the definition of a pro."

He is also a good example for the rookie.

"It's impressive to see just the last couple weeks just how [Dart] has prepared and made the transition to becoming a pro," Tierney said at minicamp. "We thought that about him, which is one of the reasons why we liked him, but he's done a really good job of coming in here and understanding what he's got to do to make himself a pro and approaching it the right way."

Matt Citak: The spring tends to be the time for optimism each year, with any shortcomings of the previous season long in the rearview mirror. I'll be the first to admit that I have fallen victim of being too positive about the team around this time of year in previous seasons. However, I do not think it's crazy to believe that the Giants could have a top defense this upcoming season, and we saw flashes of this during the spring.

The Giants had one of the league's top pass rushes for a good part of the 2024 season. Dexter Lawrence picked up a career-high 9.5 sacks, all through the first seven games of the season, before missing the final five contests. Brian Burns recorded 8.5 sacks, along with a new career-best 71 total tackles, despite playing through injuries for most of the season, while Kayvon Thibodeaux had 5.5 sacks and a career-high 17 quarterback hits in only 12 games. The Giants finished with 45 sacks on the season, which was tied for the eighth-most in the NFL, even with Lawrence and Thibodeaux missing a combined 10 outings (not to mention Azeez Ojulari missing six games, as well).

Now let's focus on the upcoming campaign, where the Giants have made several key additions to the defense throughout the offseason. For starters, Abdul Carter replaces Ojulari as the third edge rusher with Burns and Thibodeaux, although the third overall pick's athleticism and versatility should provide him with more opportunities to get on the field than Ojulari saw last year. The addition of Carter is the biggest reason why I feel so optimistic about the defense. Granted there is no contact allowed during the spring, so offensive linemen do not engage with pass rushers like they do during training camp and in actual games, but Carter's quickness and bend were very easy to see from the first practice he took the field. Talented players find a way to stand out, and Carter just looked different during team drills this spring. Whether he's lined up on the edge or inside, I have no doubt Carter is going to be a headache for opposing offensive lines.

"Abdul has some special traits about him," coach Brian Daboll told reporters during minicamp. "Some of them you can see out here, obviously his ability to bend and get off and create some issues in the backfield. But we have to play the run game, we have to play the pass game. He's smart, he's picked up things. We've used him in a number of different areas. I'm glad he's here, he's done a nice job."

But my optimism goes beyond the selection of Carter. The Giants added numerous players up front via free agency and the draft, all of whom should help improve a run defense that struggled last season. Additionally, the free agent acquisitions of Paulson Adebo and Jevón Holland should provide a significant boost to a secondary that has shown some promise over the last few seasons. It won't matter until the games actually begin in September, of course, but at least on paper, the Giants have the makings of an elite defense.

Take a look at rare photos of New York Giants training camps through the years.

25_ScheduleRelease_SingleGameTickets_1920x1080

Tickets on sale now

Limited 2025 Giants single game tickets are now available

Related Content

Advertising