Skip to main content
New York Giants homepage
Advertising

Giants News | New York Giants – Giants.com

ForF_100x30

Presented by

Fact or Fiction: X-factors & stat predictions

ABDUL-CARTER-JEVON-HOLLAND-FACT-OR-FICTION

The Giants.com crew is presented with four statements and must decide whether they are Fact or Fiction.

The Jaguars' defense is a bigger challenge than their offense.

John Schmeelk: Fiction - I really wanted to go "faction" here because this is really close. I decided to lean offense for a simple reason. In the first half this season, the Jaguars lead the NFL with 143 points. They have given the defense a lead and allowed them to play from ahead, which is advantageous to any defensive unit. Their offense has enabled them to run away with four games this year. They beat four teams by at least 17 points, including their last three games, which they have won by a combined 75 points. Trevor Lawrence is playing at a MVP level. Parker Washington is the least-known lead wide receiver in the league. Liam Coen is an elite play-caller. Their offense is balanced, produces big plays, is third in the NFL on third down conversions, and averages just under 30 points per game. They are legit.

Matt Citak: Fiction – Both the Jaguars' offense and defense rank inside the top five in terms of points, so it's hard to say one is that much bigger of a challenge than the other. But given the presence of Trevor Lawrence and all of their playmakers, I'm giving the slight edge to the offense. Lawrence is in the MVP conversation, the offensive line is playing well, and the unit has more than one talented player at each skill position. Jacksonville's offensive numbers would look even better if they weren't in so many blowouts and taking their foot off the gas in the second half most weeks. The additions of Jordan Davis and Jessie Bates III will provide their already strong defense with a boost, but I still have to go with the offense here.

J.J. McCarthy will have at least six rushing attempts.

John Schmeelk: Fiction - This will be wholly dependent on how much McCarthy decides to scramble because I don't think the Giants will lean into the designed run game for the quarterback much more than twice during the game. The Jaguars play mostly zone defense, which should theoretically make scrambling tougher. I also think the Giants will focus on running the ball effectively and limiting the times they drop back, which could limit scrambling opportunities. What will make this go the other way is if the Giants go down early in this game and have to pass while playing from behind.

Matt Citak: Fact – McCarthy reached this number for the first time with the Giants last week as his six rush attempts for 34 yards set new season highs for the young QB. The Jaguars have done a good job of limiting quarterbacks running with the ball. But with the forecast looking like it could be another wet and rainy day, the Giants might need McCarthy to lean on his rushing abilities once again. This is especially true when considering how well the Jaguars have contained opposing running backs on the ground this season.

View photos of the Giants on the practice field as they prepare for their Week 11 matchup against the Jaguars.

Abdul Carter is the X-factor for the Giants' defense on Sunday.

John Schmeelk: Fiction - Abdul Carter's ability to create pressure will be very important, especially with the Jaguars lacking an elite offensive tackle to block him one-on-one, but I don't think he will be the X-Factor. I thought about Arvell Reese because of how the Jaguars want to use a balanced offensive attack and try to manipulate the inside linebackers with play action. But I am going to go with Dru Phillips. The Jaguars best receiver, Parker Washington, lines up in the slot just under half the time. He is the Jaguars' best separator, and when the Giants bring heat on third down, or play man or match defense, Phillips will often draw him as a matchup. How he covers in those situations could decide the game.

Matt Citak: Fact – Despite only registering two sacks thus far, Carter has found a way to be a disruptive force this season, as coach John Harbaugh pointed out on Wednesday. But going up against this high-powered Jaguars offense, the Giants' defense is going to need their best pass rusher to come up with some big plays. The best chance the Giants have of slowing down Lawrence and the Jacksonville passing game is if Carter can play a big part in the pass rush getting pressure early and often on the veteran QB. One or two splash plays from the second-year edge rusher wouldn't hurt, either.

Malachi Fields is the X-factor for the Giants' offense on Sunday.

John Schmeelk: Fiction - Fields might draw Travis Hunter a lot this game if he lines up to the boundary side of the field, which is often where the X-receiver lives in the NFL. If that happens, Fields might not be a huge factor in this game. I am looking at Isaiah Likely here. The Jaguars play a lot of base defense on early downs, and those personnel packages could provide some mismatch opportunities for Likely against linebackers in coverage. When they play nickel, Jourdan Lewis is good in coverage, but Likely is too big for him. It will have to be a big day for Likely if the Giants want to win this game. I think he has it in him.

Matt Citak: Fiction – The rookie receiver has certainly begun to make more of an impact with 10 receptions for 185 yards over the last three games after totaling 12 receptions for 165 yards in his first six outings. But the offensive X-factor this week is Cam Skattebo. The second-year running back reached 100 scrimmage yards just once from Weeks 1-6 with a high of exactly 100 yards during that stretch. In his last two games, he has totaled 121 and 122 total yards of offense while scoring in each game and totaling three touchdowns during that span. The Jaguars have one of the NFL's best run defenses, but they have given up the sixth-most receptions to the running back position. He might have to make more of an impact in the passing game than on the ground, but if Skattebo can put together another strong performance, it would go a long way in helping the Giants pull out the victory Sunday.

View rare photos of the all-time history between the New York Giants and Jacksonville Jaguars.

26_SGT_Header

Single Game Tickets

Buy single game tickets to see the Giants live during the 2026 season

Related Content

Advertising