Skip to main content
New York Giants Website
Advertising

Giants News | New York Giants – Giants.com

Cover 4

Presented by

Cover 4: Final thoughts on Year 1 of new era

The Giants.com crew reflects on the first season under general manager Joe Schoen and coach Brian Daboll:

John Schmeelk: To quote Brian Daboll, the Giants "crash landed" in the playoffs. While the loss to the hated divisional rival Eagles certainly left a sour taste in the mouths of Giants fans, it shouldn't overwhelm the success of the season as a whole.

Heading into this season, an improvement to seven wins, or .500, would have been considered a successful first year for the Daboll and Joe Schoen regime. This was supposed to be at best the first year of a long-term rebuild. Instead, the Giants went 9-7-1, made the playoffs, and even won a playoff game.

More important than the record is the improvement and progress shown by some of the young, foundational players. Dexter Lawrence was the best nose tackle in football, and there's a very strong argument to make he was the best defensive tackle. He's only 25 years old and is under contract for another season.

Andrew Thomas' play continued its steady improvement in his third season, and he played like one of the best left tackles in football. He is 24 years old and plays one of the most important positions on the field. He's now a cornerstone of the future.

Daniel Jones took another leap this year protecting the football. He had the lowest interceptions per pass rate in the NFL (1.1%) this season and a career-best 67.2% completion rate. Jones also had his best year running the football with 708 yards.

Saquon Barkley had his healthiest and best year since his rookie season. Kayvon Thibodeaux improved as the season went along. Julian Love and Xavier McKinney continued to improve. Isaiah Hodgins established himself as a big part of this wide receiving corps moving forward. Rookie tight end Daniel Bellinger showed promise as a two-way tight end. Wan'Dale Robinson flashed. Evan Neal should continue to improve.

The improvement shown this year by so many young players should set a solid foundation for the future, but that doesn't mean there still isn't a lot of work to do in the draft and free agency to try to reach the level of the Eagles and the other top teams in the NFC. It should be a fun offseason to see how they do just that.

Dan Salomone: Even if they had all the cap room in the world, which they didn't last offseason, we've seen that the regime's philosophy isn't just to collect talent. The goal is to build a team. The focus on camaraderie and culture led to the franchise's best start in more than a decade. It also helped them weather the lull that is inevitable in almost every season and clinch their first playoff berth since 2016, leading to their first postseason victory since winning Super Bowl XLVI.

No one was ever going to be foolish enough to put a timetable on anything when Schoen and Daboll were hired a year ago, but at the end of the season, you needed to see progress. They certainly put a giant check mark in the column.

But now the work begins. Schoen was upfront in his season-ending press conference in saying they need to "close that gap" with the talent around the league, especially in the NFC East. Having a healthier cap will allow them to do things they weren't in Year 1.

"There were times in season where there were maybe some veteran players that we wanted to sign that would've helped us, but we just weren't able to do it," Schoen said. "That part stings throughout the season because we could've helped the roster, but just didn't have the flexibility. Yeah, to have financial flexibility, nine draft picks, to be able to devise a plan where you have a little bit more flexibility and resources, I'm definitely excited about that."

Re-live the season with the best photos from the Giants' 2022 playoff campaign.

Lance Medow: Prior to the season, I emphasized how this campaign wasn't going to be defined so much based on record but instead the continued development of the young corps, especially recent draft picks. In a salary cap era, you can't solve all your issues through free agency so that's why maximizing your prospects is so critical. This year, it's fair to say the Giants capitalized in that department.

Dexter Lawrence tops the list as he earned Pro Bowl and All-Pro honors for the first time in his career. Lawrence has been a solid player but he elevated his game so much this year that he consistently stood out for his disruptive plays, leading the team in both sacks (7.5) and quarterback hits (28), more than double the next closest player. Daniel Jones and Saquon Barkley both took a step forward in the durability department as neither missed a game due to injury. While Barkley showed flashes of his 2018 rookie year, Jones' decision making was noticeable as he led the NFL in interception percentage (1.1%). Add in Julian Love, who proved to be a valuable component on the back end with Xavier McKinney missing the bulk of the second half of the season, and you have several members of that 2019 draft class that put their stamps all across the board.

Like Jones and Barkley, Andrew Thomas also avoided serving as a spectator at any point this season and has proven to be the anchor of the offensive line at left tackle. His consistency at that position provides a sense of security up front at an extremely important position. While the 2022 draft class battled injuries, Wan'Dale Robinson, Cor'Dale Flott, Daniel Bellinger and Dane Belton all took advantage of their opportunities and made immediate contributions.

How a team finishes one season rarely dictates or guarantees how things will play out the following year. That's because the roster turnover rate in the NFL is unlike any other within the four U.S. major professional sports. That's why you need a stable nucleus of players that you draft, develop and, hopefully, have reason to invest in. If the Giants want to maintain this path, it falls on that process continuing to run smoothly.

Matt Citak: Saturday night's loss was certainly a rough way for it to end, but the 2022 season cannot be classified as anything short of a success.

Joe Schoen and Brian Daboll took over the reins of the franchise about one year ago today, inheriting a roster that just went 4-13 and hadn't topped six wins since 2016. The team had very limited cap space to spend in free agency last offseason, but did have two top seven picks in the draft and 11 picks overall to help build the roster around.

Fast forward a year, the Giants are coming off the franchise's first postseason victory since Super Bowl XLVI with some clear and obvious foundational pieces on both sides of the ball. They have a rock-solid coaching staff in place, and the success has led to head coaching interest for coordinators.

As of now, the Giants have the third-most cap space in the NFL heading into free agency to go along with nine selections in the draft (that number could increase based on compensatory picks, which have yet to be determined). The front office has shown the ability over the last year to find talent in the form of both free agents and draft picks, and now get an opportunity to shape the roster this offseason with a system already in place and a lot more resources at their disposal.

Losing in the playoffs to a division rival will always a tough pill to swallow. But in a season that not many people outside of 1925 Giants Drive gave the team a chance to seriously compete, the Giants proved a lot of people wrong. Schoen and Daboll have built the foundation for a winning football program, and it will be very exciting to see how they plan on building upon this year's success moving forward.

NYG23_PSL_DJ_1920x1080

2023 Season Tickets Now Available

Related Content

Advertising